
Should you run Oxide or Carbon on your Rust server?
Base the choice on the features players depend on and the update process you can maintain. For an existing server, a working plugin or extension that the author supports on only one framework may settle the choice.
If you are starting from scratch
For a new server on a rental, check what the host can install and maintain. If the host offers Oxide and your entire list is supported there, you already have a workable choice. If you need a Carbon-only module, check that the host offers Carbon and every other required component works with it.
If you already run a modded server
List the features you need to keep, such as moderation and raid rules. Beside each one write down the plugin and extensions and check the author's support for each framework. For example, if a required raid rule depends on a DLL its author supports only on your current framework, keep that setup until you've found and tested a replacement.
When both frameworks fit
Choose the update routine your team can maintain. Oxide publishes Rust-specific releases with game update notes. Carbon documents when its own updater changes the framework build. In either case decide who checks the framework version and tests your essential feature before players come back.