# Get two Rust moderators to apply the same rule consistently

[Rust server guides](https://rustsc.com/learn/index.html.md) / [Players and community](https://rustsc.com/learn/community/index.html.md)

Find a rule your moderators read differently. Give them the same two invented cases, collect their decisions separately and change the staff example that leaves too much to guess.

## Pick a pair with one meaningful difference

Pinebridge's market rule says ‘Keep the public road clear.’ Case A shows a player placing a foundation across the entire ramp for a storage extension. Case B shows a booth on the edge of the road with the ramp and exit still usable. Both pictures are staged on a test world and come with the same time and location context.

Ask the moderators to write what they can see, the words in the rule they rely on, what they would ask the builder to do and when they would escalate. Collect the answers before they compare notes.

## Find the point where judgment split

In this example both moderators would ask the first builder to reopen the ramp. They disagree on the booth.

| Reading | Next move |
| --- | --- |
| One moderator treats any footprint over the painted line as a violation. | Check whether the boundaries were published and explain the line if the community wants a fixed boundary. |
| The other looks only at whether players can pass. | Specify the actual passage players must keep usable if that is the outcome the community wants. |

## Test the clarification on a third case

Pinebridge chooses passage. It adds a staff example: ‘Both ends of the ramp and the doorway to the recycler must stay usable. Ask the builder to move an obstruction and show the blocked route.’ It also adds both examples to the staff note so the next volunteer can see the difference.

Give both moderators a third picture of a queue blocking the doorway with no building piece in the way. If one sends a builder warning and the other asks a steward to move the queue, the examples still leave a gap. Clarify when to direct people and when to address a structure. End the exercise when both can name the next action and the evidence behind it.

## Sources

- [Discord: developing moderator guidelines](https://discord.com/safety/developing-moderator-guidelines)
- [Discord: managing moderation teams](https://discord.com/safety/managing-moderation-teams)

## Related resources

- [How to write Rust server rules players can use](https://rustsc.com/learn/community/write-rust-server-rules-players-can-use/index.html.md)
- [Run a shadow shift for a new Rust moderator](https://rustsc.com/learn/community/run-a-shadow-shift-for-a-rust-moderator/index.html.md)

---

HTML version: https://rustsc.com/learn/community/calibrate-rust-moderators-on-one-rule/
